以谬传谬是颇有趣的事件

pengsk2003

比来流传一个Sydney House and Unit Performance 图。得多人开始在这个根底上剖析来剖析去。
以前曾经有人指出这个图并非房价变动图。而是“收益”幅度的图---收益升高仍是有收益房价上涨或回升。  请找同时代房价index变动图。

请爱好寻根究底或购买有corelogic账户的提供 “performance”的统计阐明。

binsi

你说的是我发的两张图么？

出处在这里，假如了解有过错感激斧正！

The history of Sydney house price movements, in one chart

It was posted by Tim Lawless, CoreLogic’s Head of Research, on Twitter today, showing both the price upswings and downswings in Sydney’s housing market over the past 20 years.

Tim Lawless Twitter Post

CoreLogic: What Have Periods of Decline Looked Like Over Recent Years and How Long Have Markets Taken to Recover?

vbcoco

这个图其余人也发过量次。“听说”是只要“同一套在一年内最少有两次买卖记载”的（而后算差价）。即：统计办法或算法不同，一样数据出来的后果不同。

拿他跟price index对比一下。 或请你来讲一下你对图片横纵轴的数字含意了解。
see？

wanghuijune

旧事原文里说的是
It was posted by Tim Lawless, CoreLogic’s Head of Research, on Twitter today, showing both the price upswings and downswings in Sydney’s housing market over the past 20 years.

而后在Tim Lawless的twitter上也没有提过“同一套在一年内最少有两次买卖记载”。不知你这听说从哪里来？

假如说是“收益”幅度，那末这个收益幅度应该怎么来了解呢，假如是从97年前某一个时间的房价为基准开始计算收益，那末的确总收益一定仍是为正，但若你是在2017年的最高点买入，那末将来几年收益极可能就为负了啊。

Tim Lawless也说：In a
clear downwards trend
, Melbourne and Sydney auction clearance rates from @corelogicau slipped below 60% last week.

https://twitter.com/timlawless/status/996883146082734080

CoreLogic的这个文章也有悉尼历次房价降落的统计，这应该就是房价自身的降落吧？

Peak to Trough Declines Sydney

There has been a number of periods of decline in Sydney over the past 38 years with the greatest fall recorded between 1988-91 when values fell by -十一.6% in 28 months.

四四方方

何苦揭-穿皇帝的新装呢，人家原本很high的，将来就靠炒房博得人生巅峰，而后就是满口龙虾鲍鱼，常常买几套压压惊，活在宇宙核心。